Body

We dove deep into Harris County’s eviction court system. The poor quality of recordkeeping stunned us.

PERSPECTIVES :  Nov. 19, 2026 HOUSING

Courtroom

A comprehensive study of local eviction courts revealed inadequate, inconsistent and sometimes erroneous recordkeeping that impedes accountability.


By Andrew Kim

Kim is a research analyst for the Center for Housing and Neighborhoods at the Kinder Institute for Urban Research.


Each year, tens of thousands of households struggling to make ends meet find themselves in Harris County's complicated eviction courts. These residents often lack legal representation as they face off against deeper-pocketed landlords — and that's if they have the time and resources to show up at all.

Over the past two years, we have analyzed over 320,000 eviction cases in Harris County, aiming to provide a comprehensive picture of how this obscure system works and whether tenants are being treated fairly. We've tracked outcomes for landlords and tenants who appeared before 22 justice of the peace, or JP, judges and appealed rulings to the county civil courts over a five-year period. We did this by downloading, cleaning and analyzing large databases from the two courts, and by employing powerful document-scanning technology to produce a first-of-its-kind look at eviction appeal records.

Our work revealed important findings that we published Wednesday. Some JP judges rule in favor of landlords at notably higher rates than their colleagues, even within the same precinct. Many of these cases are “overturned,” or reach a different outcome, when they’re appealed.

But even after hundreds of hours of work diving into this system, we remain deeply frustrated by gaps in our knowledge. We couldn’t always track what transpired in a case or the reasoning behind JP and county judges’ rulings.

This frustration largely stems from inadequate, inconsistent and sometimes erroneous recordkeeping. Even with significant investment in research, expertise in navigating the system and experience extracting data from messy systems, the lack of quality recordkeeping makes it extremely difficult to identify issues and propose evidence-based solutions. 

Improved recordkeeping would benefit tenants, landlords, researchers, policymakers and more across Harris County. 

Residents could more easily correct errors on reports that tenant screeners and credit agencies use to make decisions with life-altering consequences. Landlords would likewise have more accurate tenant screening data. Legislators would have more reliable and detailed information to guide their decision-making, as would advocates and tenant-rights lawyers working to keep more people housed.

Taken together, these improvements would reduce the risk of due process violations and have long-lasting positive effects on our local population.

Studying the system

We started this research two years ago out of a desire to understand issues of fairness and due process raised by Lone Star Legal Aid, a statewide nonprofit that provides free legal representation in eviction courts to thousands of Texans each year. In our early review of the system, we particularly noticed that large spreadsheets documenting case records and outcomes were not available for tens of thousands of eviction appeals.

We decided this was a worthy cause to pursue, particularly given similar problems in other metro areas. In the following months, we spent hundreds of hours researching and consulting with judges, lawyers, advocacy organizations and other researchers to develop our plan of action.  

We used databases that summarize case information to analyze filings at the JP level,  but these databases required extensive, time-consuming cleaning to accurately label the outcomes of cases. We found over 17,000 cases where a judgment was erroneously entered into the record, and occasionally found documented dispositions that didn’t accurately reflect case outcomes, an issue that could result in credit and tenant screening agencies misidentifying the result of a case. 

To understand the outcomes of appealed cases, we had to develop a methodology to extract text from hundreds of thousands of documents to determine the outcomes of appealed cases. (See our detailed methodology and research process here.)

Many of the documents we reviewed were inconsistent or difficult to read. Different courts used different forms and language to document the same information. Many appeal case records were poorly scanned or had stamps covering up important details.

Sometimes, key information was missing. The courts do not always reliably record what happens in a case or keep key documents that should be present, such as a written answer to an appeal.

After all of this work, we could document many aspects of the eviction court system, including overall case disposition totals and differing rates of rulings by JP judges.

Yet we still couldn’t find good details about proceedings in each case, reliably determine whether a tenant became unhoused as a result of a legal ruling or confidently evaluate the performance of JP or county judges. As a result, we can’t reliably offer the public data that would help it identify systemic issues, hold JP courts and judges accountable or address the root causes of inequities in the eviction process.

The path forward

We believe many of these issues can be addressed.

Several steps can be taken to improve recordkeeping. The courts can more clearly codify and standardize processes for recording case events and outcomes, including settlements and whether a tenant remained housed. To that end, while current regulations don’t allow courts to require parties in eviction cases to use court-provided forms, local JP judges could encourage their use and make them more accessible.

While recent state legislation and court action have better codified what must be documented in eviction courts, more direction related to the process and format for such records would shed light on the system. This would provide a check on landlords who don’t always file proper documentation, such as notices to vacate and proof of failure to pay rent, and help improve efficiency.

Linking eviction case numbers in JP courts to appeals in county courts also would help, as would standardizing more language and terminology used across the courts. Unifying and connecting these databases could also provide easier integration with regional resources, allowing, for example, for the ability to inform school districts about an impending eviction of a student’s household.

In addition, county leaders can take action by providing more training for JP judges on recordkeeping and increasing oversight of compliance.

Finally, local voters can influence the courts by making informed decisions at the ballot box when they vote for JP judges. While these officials garner relatively little attention during election season, they’re ultimately accountable to the will of Houstonians.

These actions could produce positive change for tenants, landlords, researchers, community organizations and the county at large. A clearer picture of the courts will help everyone understand where issues in the eviction process lie, a necessary first step for improving this consequential process.

RELATED RESEARCH
Courtroom
How Evictions and Appeals Differ by Precinct and Judge in Harris County
Nov. 18, 2026

Eviction outcomes vary significantly depending on the precinct and presiding judge.

RELATED URBAN EDGE
A tenant looks at an eviction notice.
In these Harris County neighborhoods, landlords seek to evict renters at the highest rates
INSIGHTS :  Jul. 20, 2026

Parts of northern Harris County and southern Houston saw the most eviction filings in 2024, a Kinder Institute analysis shows.

HOUSING
Body
Mailing Address

6100 Main St. MS-208
Houston, TX 77005-1892

kinder@rice.edu
713-348-4132 

Subscribe to our e-newsletter

Physical Address

Rice University
Kraft Hall
6100 Main Street, Suite 305
Houston, TX 77005-1892

Featured Sponsor

Support the Kinder Institute