The Houston area has one of the highest eviction filing rates in the U.S. Evictions inflict lasting harm on tenants — damaging credit, increasing debt and contributing to homelessness, job loss and poor health and educational outcomes. They also cost landlords through lost rent, legal fees and preparation of units for new occupants.
Between Jan. 1, 2019, and May 30, 2024, over 320,000 eviction cases were filed across Harris County Justice of the Peace (JP) courts, distributed unequally across and within precincts. This brief finds that eviction outcomes varied significantly by precincts and presiding judges.
Key findings
- Precincts with more initial judgments against tenants tended to see more overturned cases. The overlap of high caseloads and high overturn rates suggests that heavy dockets may prevent adequate case review. (Note: “Overturned” in this report refers to appealed cases resulting in a dismissal or final judgment in favor of the tenant. An overturned result may indicate that a case was settled out of court, was not fairly considered by the JP or a procedural violation occurred, among other potential outcomes.)
- JP judge selection impacts case outcomes independent of precinct and location. Because landlords can choose which court — and therefore which judge — will hear their initial case, this can lead to inequitable outcomes for tenants.
- Appeals matter for tenants: While 52.5% of initial JP rulings favor landlords, 62.8% of appealed cases were overturned (61.5% dismissed and 1.3% in the tenant’s favor).
While this analysis does not identify the root causes behind these disparities, it highlights clear opportunities for targeted intervention. Researchers offer several recommendations for streamlining the legal process and mitigating displacement:
- Randomize case assignments between the two JPs of a precinct to equalize internal caseloads.
- Redraw precinct boundaries to alleviate uneven caseload burdens across Harris County.
- Improve recordkeeping practices, including linking JP and county case numbers and clearly recording final dispositions.
- Increase awareness of the appeals process among tenants.
- Fund outcome monitoring for eviction filings to better track and understand how evictions impact county residents.
