By Flávio Cunha
Cunha is the director of the Center for Economic Mobility at the Kinder Institute for Urban Research.
Houston is a region of extraordinary economic dynamism. Our economy creates jobs, attracts businesses and draws people from across the country and around the world in search of opportunity.
Yet economic growth does not necessarily translate into economic mobility. A region can prosper even as many of its residents struggle to improve their economic circumstances. The ultimate measure of our economic success should be not simply how much wealth our economy generates, but whether that prosperity creates opportunities for individuals and families to build better lives.
The findings from the Kinder Institute for Urban Research’s new, comprehensive reports on economic mobility in Greater Houston make clear that the region faces significant challenges.
Between 2020 and 2024, about 1 in 5 children under age 6 lived in poverty, the highest rate among the nation's 10 largest metropolitan areas. During the same period, about 1 in 8 young people ages 16 to 24 were neither enrolled in school nor employed, also the highest rate among those metropolitan areas. And only 60% of households headed by adults ages 30 to 34 earned enough from work to cover their basic necessities.
These are different manifestations of a common problem: Too many Houstonians are unable to translate the opportunities generated by our regional economy into economic security.
Recognizing this challenge is an important first step, but it raises a more difficult question: How will we know whether Houston is making meaningful progress toward greater economic mobility? The Houston Economic Mobility Coalition was created to bring together dozens of organizations working across basic needs, jobs, housing, education and health. These organizations operate in different sectors, serve different populations and pursue different objectives, but they share a broader aspiration: improving the economic prospects of Houston residents.
If we want their collective efforts to contribute to that aspiration, we need more than a collection of individual programs and organizational performance measures. We need a common understanding of what success would look like for our region. With that objective in mind, my colleagues and I at the Kinder Institute have developed a proposal for four North Stars that could help guide Houston's efforts through 2040.
- Children grow up out of poverty
- Children grow up in places that pay a dividend
- Young people stay connected to school or work
- Adults reach economic security
The four North Stars follow important stages of the life course, beginning in early childhood and extending to the period when many young adults are establishing households and raising children of their own. They are intended to complement one another, providing a more complete picture of our region than any single indicator could offer.
They are also preliminary recommendations, not decisions made on behalf of the Coalition. We are publishing the reasoning behind them precisely because we believe that choosing what Houston should aspire to achieve deserves careful examination and public discussion.
Exploring the North Stars
A North Star should provide a shared objective that organizations can pursue through different approaches while remaining accountable to a common outcome.
Importantly, a North Star is not a measure of organizational activity, such as the number of people enrolled in a training program or families receiving assistance. A North Star must instead capture an outcome that matters for residents themselves.
Choosing such measures is considerably more difficult than it may appear. Economic mobility is multidimensional, and no single indicator can adequately capture all the circumstances that shape people's economic prospects. At the same time, selecting a large number of indicators would undermine their ability to provide a common direction.
In selecting our North Stars, we established four requirements for each measure: reliability, validity, responsiveness to meaningful change and transparency. The resulting measures are based on publicly available data, can be compared across metropolitan areas and describe conditions that matter in themselves rather than relying on predictions of what might happen in the future.
With those considerations in mind, we propose the following:
North Star No. 1: Children grow up out of poverty
A substantial body of research documents strong relationships between childhood economic circumstances and outcomes later in life. Poverty is also an undesirable condition in itself. A child who grows up in a family struggling to meet basic needs experiences immediate deprivation, regardless of what that child's economic circumstances will be at age 30 or 40.
The available evidence suggests that Houston has considerable room for improvement. About 21% of children under age 6 live below the federal poverty line and 10% live in families whose incomes fall below half that threshold.
North Star No. 2: Children grow up in places that pay a dividend
Research on neighborhood effects has demonstrated that the places where children grow up can have important consequences for their economic outcomes in adulthood. Access to educational opportunities, healthy environments and other neighborhood resources can influence children's development, with the benefits accumulating as children spend more time in those settings.
At the same time, homeownership represents an important form of asset ownership for many American families and is associated with greater residential stability. These considerations motivate a measure that combines two dimensions of economic opportunity: the share of households with children under age 6 that own their homes in neighborhoods classified as offering high opportunity. (We also recommend publishing a companion measure capturing access to these neighborhoods regardless of homeownership.)
According to our report, only 31% of Houston-area households with young children meet these conditions, placing the region in the bottom quarter of the 50 largest metropolitan areas.
North Star No. 3: Young people stay connected to school or work
Transitions from adolescence to adulthood are rarely linear. Some young people move directly from high school into employment, whereas others pursue additional education or training before establishing careers. What matters is that they have opportunities to remain engaged in activities through which they can acquire knowledge, skills, experience and earnings.
For that reason, we propose measuring the share of young people ages 16 to 24 who are neither enrolled in school nor employed. In Houston, 13% of individuals in this age group are disconnected by this definition, with the rate increasing to 18% among those ages 20 to 24.
North Star No. 4: Adults reach economic security
A family can live above the federal poverty line and still struggle to afford housing, food, childcare, transportation and healthcare. Moreover, the cost of meeting these needs differs across communities and household types.
We therefore propose using the Texas Self-Sufficiency Standard, which estimates the resources required to cover basic necessities based on household composition and local prices, and focusing on adults in their early 30s to measure adult economic security. At younger ages, earnings may reflect temporary periods of education, training or early career exploration. By the early 30s, earnings provide a more informative measure of economic position, and many individuals are beginning to establish families of their own.
Our findings indicate that only 3 in 5 households headed by adults in this age range earn enough from work to meet the applicable standard. Particularly revealing is that nearly two-thirds of households falling below the standard include someone who works full time throughout the year. This finding challenges the assumption that employment alone guarantees economic security.
Our next steps
The four North Stars presented here are the beginning of a conversation rather than its conclusion.
This summary provides only a broad overview of our proposal. Our research team has sought to make the proposal transparent by documenting how each measure was selected, what it captures, what it leaves out and how it might be misinterpreted.
The Coalition must now consider whether these are the right aspirations for Houston, whether the proposed measures adequately represent them and whether alternative or additional indicators would better serve our collective objectives. We hope this process also involves engaging employers, educators, researchers, public institutions, community organizations and residents across the region.
Houston's economic future will be shaped by many forces, some within our control and others beyond it. Technological change, shifts in labor demand, demographic trends and developments in the broader national economy will create new challenges and opportunities. We cannot predict all of them, nor can we specify today every intervention that will be needed between now and 2040.
What we can do is establish a shared understanding of the outcomes we want to improve, commit to measuring them transparently and use credible evidence to guide our decisions as circumstances evolve. We believe Houston has the institutions, resources and capacity for collaboration necessary to make meaningful progress. But that progress should ultimately be judged by what happens to the people who live here, not simply by the scale of our ambitions or the extent of our efforts.
If, by 2040, more children are growing up out of poverty, more families have access to opportunities, more young people are connected to education and work and more adults can achieve economic security, we will have accomplished something far more consequential than improving a collection of statistics. We will have helped make Houston a region where prosperity translates into greater opportunity for its residents.
